The Power of Small Commitments

“It’s easier to resist at the beginning than at the end.” — Leonardo da Vinci

What drives someone to chase a thief across a beach, agree to place a billboard in their front yard, or show up for a reservation they might otherwise forget?

The answer: Consistency—one of the most powerful and underestimated principles of ethical influence.

In this blog, we’ll unpack how the Principle of Consistency and how it works to shape human behavior and decision-making. You’ll walk away with practical tools, research-backed insights, and real-life stories to help you influence with integrity, build stronger relationships, and increase conversions in business and life.

What Is the Principle of Consistency?

In short, the Principle of Consistency states:

People feel psychological pressure to behave consistently with what they’ve previously said or done—especially when those actions were made voluntarily, publicly, and actively.

This isn’t just about following through. It’s about identity. Once someone sees themselves a certain way—supporter, customer, leader, loyal friend—they feel compelled to act in alignment with that identity.

This desire to be (and appear) consistent is so powerful that even the smallest commitments can drive massive behavioral change.

Let’s explore.

From “No” to “Yes” with a Credit Card-Sized Commitment

In a classic study, researchers in Palo Alto knocked on doors asking residents to put a giant “Drive Carefully” billboard in their yard.

Not surprisingly, only 17% agreed. But in another version of the study, researchers asked for a small favor first—a simple agreement to support safe driving, followed by displaying a tiny card in their window.

Weeks later, those who had made the smaller commitments were asked again about the billboard. This time? 76% said yes.

That’s a 447% increase in compliance.

Lesson: People are far more likely to say yes to a big request when they’ve already said yes to a smaller, consistent action.

 

The Psychology Behind the Principle

Psychologists tell us we each carry a deep, often subconscious need to act in a way that matches our past behaviors, public statements, or personal identity.

• Active Commitments (e.g., “Yes, I will do this.”) are far more influential than passive acknowledgments (“Sure” or “I heard you.”).

• Public Declarations heighten accountability and desire for follow-through.

• Voluntary Choices amplify the internal ownership of behavior.

When we choose freely, we believe more deeply.

Guarding a Stranger’s Radio

In another study, a man asked someone on the beach, “Would you watch my radio while I swim?” Later, an actor “stole” the radio.

• Without the prior request: 20% took action.

• With the request: 95% chased after the thief.

That’s a nearly 500% increase in intervention—all because of a small commitment made moments earlier.

How a Restaurant Cut No-Shows by 67%

Gordon Sinclair ran a popular restaurant in Chicago, but had a 30% no-show rate for reservations.

The fix? He trained staff to ask a simple question during bookings:

“Will you please call if you need to cancel?”
(Then pause and wait for an answer.)

The result? Guests gave an active yes—“Yes, I will”—and the no-show rate dropped from 30% to 10%.

Takeaway: Always seek the active yes, not the passive or counterfeit one.

The 3 Types of “Yes”

Understanding the difference between yeses is essential:

1. Active Yes: A firm, conscious commitment (“Yes, I will”).

2. Confirmation Yes: An acknowledgment, not a commitment (“Yes, I heard”).

3. Counterfeit Yes: A fake agreement just to end the conversation (“Yeah, sure…”).

If you’re a coach, salesperson, or leader—train yourself to recognize and seek active yeses.

The Loyalty Card Hack

Imagine being committed without even knowing it.

In a gas station loyalty program, customers were told they needed 10 stamps to earn a free car wash—but they were given two stamps for free upfront.

Compared to those who started from zero stamps, these customers:

• Were twice as likely to complete the card

• Came back sooner for their next visit

  Insight: When people feel they’ve already started something, they’re more likely to finish it. It’s called “progress bias.”

How to Use Consistency in Your Business or Influence Strategy

Here are five practical ways to use the Principle of Consistency ethically:

1. Start with a Micro-Commitment

Ask prospects or team members to take a small action—download a guide, say “yes” to a 5-minute call, or join a free webinar.

2. Use the “Will You…” Technique

Instead of saying “Let me know,” say:

“Will you follow up with me by Friday?”
Pause and wait for a reply.

3. Frame Actions Around Identity

Instead of asking someone to “do” something, ask them to be someone.

“As a committed leader, would you be open to sharing your plan with the team?”

4. Make the Commitment Visible

Whether in sales, health, or culture-building, have people write down or say their intentions aloud.

5. Emphasize Freedom of Choice

Saying “It’s your choice” can actually increase compliance by up to 400%.

Reflection Questions

Use these to apply the principle in your leadership, sales, or communication strategy:

• Where in your business or life do you need to seek active (not passive) commitments?

• What small step can you ask for that aligns with a bigger outcome?

• Are you unintentionally accepting confirmation or counterfeit yeses?

• How can you reframe your requests around identity and consistency?

• In what ways can you make commitments public or visible to strengthen follow-through?

The Ethical Edge of Influence

Consistency isn’t about manipulation—it’s about alignment. When used with integrity, this principle helps people step into their best selves and follow through on their stated values.

As Cialdini teaches:

“People want to be consistent with what they have previously said or done, especially if that commitment is public, voluntary, and active.”

When you understand this principle—and apply it with respect—you don’t just get more “yeses.” You help people become who they say they want to be.

Ready to Apply the Principle of Consistency?

If you're a business leader or entrepreneur who wants to build stronger relationships, close more sales, or lead change more effectively—then mastering this principle is non-negotiable.

💡 Want more insights like this?
Subscribe to the Growth Insights Newsletter for powerful strategies rooted in behavioral science, influence, and leadership.

Or, book a strategy session and let’s identify how you can use ethical influence to grow your business with consistency.